Haiti

Back to Home Print This Page Email This Page
Haiti Banner Header

CIR Doctors Respond to the Crisis in Haiti

When the country of Haiti was struck by a massive earthquake on January 12, 2010, hundreds of resident physicians volunteered to help with relief efforts, and dozens were deployed in the past three months. These are their stories.

Moment to moment frustrations are nothing compared to those faced by the Haitians

I've been back from Haiti for 2 weeks now. I dropped right back into the life of a busy surgical resident with all of the daily challenges and frustrations of trying to care for my patients in a hectic county hospital in Los Angeles -- except that now the memories from Haiti remind me that my moment to moment frustrations are nothing compared to those faced by the Haitian people I was lucky enough to meet.

I spent a week working in Hopital Bernard Mevs in Port au Prince which is jointly run by Project Medishare and two Haitian surgeons.

It has been six months since the earthquake. To the visitor it seems that the work of rebuilding Port au Prince has scarcely begun. Piles of rubble are everywhere. There did not appear to be any organized effort to clear it. Once in a while I saw a lone figure pulling rocks from a pile. One man told me he was still searching for the bodies of his family members. Tent cities have begun the metamorphosis into shanty towns. People carry on with the business of daily life as best they can. I saw women washing their children in water flowing freely down the gutters. Women selling dusty 3rd and 4th-hand goods, shoes with worn soles, T shirts with stains and holes, mangos, bananas, and dusty packets of crackers. I saw women selling water in single serving plastic pouches from baskets balanced precariously on their heads. Everyone seemed to be doing their best to just make do.

The patients and their families at the hospital were given meals twice daily, delivered directly from the UN. Within 30 minutes of delivery the food was all eaten. There was scarcely little food to be found at any other time. Everyone seemed very hungry.

Despite this there was an air of openness and warmth between people. People greeted each other with kisses and smiles and phrases like "Hello my princess! Hello my beauty!" When patients were in duress their neighboring patients or the families of other patients would offer hugs and caresses, even to total strangers. The generosity of warmth and affection was overwhelming and beautiful and contagious.

Read More

 

Posted By: Dr. Anisa Buck on 8/9/2010 11:32:00 AM

comments (0)

I put my Drop in the Ocean... if you put yours we can fill that Ocean

I tell everybody about my experience in Haiti that I put my drop in the ocean, this only can be comprehended when somebody sees with his own eyes the need in Haiti. But I also like to say that if everybody is participating we can fill that ocean.

 

Posted By: Dr. Valentin Grigore Guset on 8/9/2010 11:29:00 AM

comments (0)

Recent report back from a Bronx CIR member in Haiti

I worked in the ER of Project Medishare, where we saw many patients with complaints ranging from fractured bones to hernias, to inoperable cancers. We had much of the equipment that exists in modern hospitals in the United States, but often things had to be be reused whereas in the US, they would have been discarded. Improvising was key in treating many patients because supplies were limited. The patients were incredibly grateful for the services we provided, and I have never felt so good in providing care! We worked long hours and did overnight calls, delivered babies, stabilized trauma patients, and a whole lot more.

It was overall a very worthwhile experience, and I felt my expertise was clearly needed. Furthermore, the staff worked hand in hand to really get things done to the best of out abilities. I would really like to return, especially after Project Medishare will be moving to a more permanent location. I am very grateful to have experienced the kindness and warmth of the Haitian people and to have been a part of such a great international effort.

Alison William
Dr. Alison Willam, a Lincoln Hospital resident, was in Haiti from May 22-27, 2010

 

Posted By: Alison Willam on 6/4/2010 5:12:00 PM

comments (0)

Port au Prince - The Land's Betrayal

[Dr. Jonel Daphnis, an emergency medicine resident at King's County Hospital in Brooklyn, went to Haiti as part of the National Organization of the Advancement of Haitians - New York Chapter (NOAH-NY). He took some stunning photographs and wrote powerful introductions to the two albums he has posted online, capturing the devastation to the land as well as the experience of the people in Port-au-Prince.] 

Port au Prince - the People

"We saved lives...but it was the people that saved our souls. We were baptized in their misery, their pain, their suffering and reborn through their gratitude, their health, their love. They were proud of our service, knowledge and commitment. We were humbled by their strength, passion and resolve. They were baptized in the anarchy of Nature, of disaster vultures feeding on their carnage to pad CV’s, bank accounts, image award fodder, they were reborn in a grace of Palestine, a Flemangista Surgeon’s hands, and a medical mind of Franklinville. We gave, they took. They gave, we took. We all grew. This was our reason for being...to cleanse their feet to only have ours washed in return. Welcome to Emily and my Ayiti. Welcome home."

 




Port au Prince - The Land's Betrayal


Dominique Bayard pulled us aside and had to share what happened to her one night as her walls shook and the earth trembled. She was frightened, unsure but posed and collected. What frightened her was not the earth betraying her every sense of security...it was the neighbors jolted back one month reliving The Event. Crying to the heavens for the Creator’s acknowledgement that they exist and to not let the Earth do to Haiti what it did without mercy a short month before. The fear that marched up her spine came from the blood curdling shrills of neighbors whose time moorings became unhinged with the aftershocks shifting nightmares into reality. They were at the mercy of the merciless, the faceless, and the betrayer of a proud people whose blood soaked and freed its soil.


 

Posted By: Dr. Jonel Daphnis on 5/18/2010 11:26:00 AM

comments (1)

"...a few fans, a portable suction machine, twenty patients, two determined nurses, and just about nothing else

Dr. Nick Nelson, an internal medicine resident at Highland Hospital in Oakland, CA, shared some of his photos with us from his March trip with CIR. They give a good sense of how local hospitals are getting by with whatever scarce resources they can collect.

Nick outside ICU
"This is me outside the "ICU" at HUEH, which consisted of a tent with a few fans, a portable suction machine, twenty patients, two determined nurses, and just about nothing else."


PICU
"This is the PICU at a tent hospital - it's a small subdivision of a large tent partitioned off by some shelving units containing a few portable incubators and some very sick babies."

Pharmacy-1 
"This is pharmacy storage.  I liked this shot because of this random selection of medications, some of which were donated from Israel and are therefore only labeled in Hebrew and some of which were donated by a guy in Miami."


Read More

 

Posted By: Heather Appel on 5/14/2010 10:22:00 AM

comments (0)

Images of the Relief Efforts

Thank you to Dr. Aaron Harries from Alameda County Medical Center for sharing these photos with us.



Pictured in the slideshow are: Dr. Harries, Dr. Shankar LeVine, Dr. Molly Moore, Haitian translator Nixon at Project Medishare field hospital.

 

Posted By: Heather Appel on 4/30/2010 4:16:00 PM

comments (0)

Births, Deaths and Big Decisions

"The basic things we took for granted made it really challenging," said Dr. Lynette Leighton, a family medicine resident at San Francisco General Hospital, after spending a week on the internal medicine service at the University of Miami field hosital. 

"By the day I left, they were starting to get running water. Every day it seemed like huge changes were happening. We were also working with a patient population that was no longer acute, traumatic injuries; we were dealing with subacute injuries of patients who had survived."

Even though weeks had passed since the earthquake, the medical needs were overwhelming.

"A lot of the people we treated were spinal chord injury patients who had been crushed by the rubble. Some of them actually had surgeries but it was months later than what you would get here," she said. "We were really fighting to do the best we could . . . It’s not clear if  this huge population that survived is going to be doing well in the future."

She described the emotional highs and lows. "There were a lot of women who lost their whole family who were pregnant, and were having babies," Dr. Leighton said. "Over a couple days there were six kids that died. It was really devastating for the staff -- you could hear mothers wailing. Then when a baby was born, everybody was really happy."

It was the first time many doctors had to grapple with saving one patient over another. Dr. Leighton recalled a patient who suffered through the night before being put on a ventilator, only to be taken off soon after because a younger patient needed it. 

"Picking one life over another put us in a place that was really hard, but also made you feel that you were doing something big,"  she said.

 

 

Posted By: Heather Appel on 4/22/2010 4:44:00 PM

comments (0)

CIR members in the News

While many have been critical of the media presence in Haiti, especially in the days right after the earthquake, there has been some excellent coverage of the relief efforts undertaken by heatlhcare workers and other volunteers. 

CIR members have been featured in several news stories:

Hard Lessons, Hard lessons, humility for big-city doctors in Haiti     - CNN story featuring Dr. Hiba Georges, an anesthesiology resident at Boston Medical Center

Returning Home to Haiti — Providing Medical Care after the Earthquake - New England Journal of Medicine article written by Dr. Georges's colleague, Dr. Paul Delonnay

Have you seen other media coverage of the earthquake that includes CIR doctors or presents a unique perspective on the situation? Share it with us in the comments section.

 

 

Posted By: Heather Appel on 4/8/2010 4:09:00 PM

comments (0)

Being Strong Patient Advocates, at Home or Abroad

“The reason I went into medicine was to do international work,” said Dr. Shankar LeVine, an Emergency Medicine resident at Alameda County Medical Center.  “When I was picking residencies, I actually picked Highland Hospital for the training it provides -- it’s as close to an international disaster setting as you get – huge volume of patients, severe illnesses, and few resources. I knew if I came here, we’d be able to send groups out to international disaster areas.”

When the disaster struck Haiti, Dr. LeVine looked into several organizations that were recruiting health care workers, but didn’t feel most of them were appropriate for him as an intern. “Having worked in international settings before, I’m sensitive to the idea of people who are not clinically saavy going to an environment and doing work beyond their comfort,” he said. He only wanted to go if there was access to adequate supervision and attending. He found that was true of CIR’s partner organization, Project Medishare, but not of other programs.

While Dr. LeVine and his cohort were based at the field hospital set up on the site of the UN compound, they were in touch with colleagues working at the General  Hospital in Port-au-Prince.

“We realized what a big difference there was between the two sites, so we tried to bring surgical patients in need of acute care from the General to Medishare, and took doctors who didn’t have as much to do to the General for a day,” Dr.LeVine said. The next day they were able to take eight doctors from the field hospital to the General hospital and bring back three surgical patients to Project Medishare.

One of the big takeaway messages for Dr. LeVine was the importance of being a patient advocate in any environment. 

“I think in the states we come across problems – like patients can’t get treatment because they’re not insured for them,” Dr. LeVine said. “But in this environment, when you see a patient, there’s always going to be reasons to not give that patient certain care…If someone needs proper pain management and are not getting it, it’s easy to say, ‘We don’t have the right medications, we can’t do general anesthetic because they have an airway problem. . . ’ There are always barriers. In an environment outside most of our comfort zones, it’s easy to say we can’t do it. Some people were more flexible, and that came from being very strong patient advocates," Dr. Levine said.

 

Posted By: Heather Appel on 4/6/2010 12:18:00 PM

comments (0)

A Life-Changing Experience

Tyler Reynolds

I have been a part of medical missions in the past, but nothing could have prepared me for the subacute needs of the Haitian people in the weeks after the disaster of January 12th.  As I am currently in a PGY-4 research year in General Surgery, and so my flexibility could not have been better for scheduling travel.  I did my research and applied through several organizations and Project Medishare, in conjunction with the University of Miami, was the most promising route.  With the financial and planning assistance of CIR and SEIU to get me to Miami, Project Medishare then took over, and the experience was life-changing!

The experience from a medical standpoint was awesome.  I worked with a Japanese trauma surgeon, a retired general surgeon who taught nonstop, an incredible trauma surgeon trained on the East Coast who managed to provide different perspectives in treatment every day, and several junior residents.  We even had a fantastic PA and medical student to complete the team.  I still don't know if I was just lucky to have such a well-functioning team or the circumstances promote a general sense of comaraderie.  I do know that the group of people I worked with (everyone at the hospital) were there to serve... and it was great!  No begging for tests, no complaints... only helping hands everywhere, support for the tough times, and more new friends than I can count.

I arrived to find "deluxe" camping accomodations and a well-planned medical compound.  Although filled to capacity with patients, my first seven days were spent with a full complement of medical personnel including ancillary staff and interpreters.  In some ways, this facility ran more smoothly and I had more assistance than back home at County!  My last three days were spent with a skeleton crew as most people had seven day stints and left.  I enjoyed my time so much that I elected to stay the additional days to smooth the signout and transition to the new team.

A quick word about the Haitian people.  I was lucky enough to meet a Pastor who brought in a woman from a rural town for evaluation and then offered to drive me around. I saw first-hand the resiliency, gratitude, and love for each other in the beautiful Haitian people.  Families units are tight, as expected, and closer after losing loved ones.  One security guard (hired by Medishare), lost his sister, brothers, parents and home in the earthquake.  After talking to him for a while, he is still in shock... moving on the only way he can after losing everything.

 

Read More

 

Posted By: Tyler Reynolds, MD on 3/30/2010 3:24:00 PM

comments (2)