On October 8th, an ICE agent in disguise as a construction worker shot Oscar Belgal, a New York resident, in his car with a 5-year-old child in the back seat. Immediately after receiving emergency treatment, Belgal was taken into ICE custody, effectively disappearing from his friends and family. This was, in no uncertain terms, an act of indefensible brutality – the latest in a long string of public shootings and assaults by immigration enforcement agents that underscore the state violence that our federal government is unleashing upon our communities.
We, as physicians, definitively condemn these acts of unjustifiable violence. The assaults perpetrated by federal immigration agents occur within systems that prioritize punitive enforcement over human dignity, community well-being, and public health. Violent immigration enforcement imposes physical bodily harm, sows terror and trauma in vulnerable people, and diverts resources from programs that would truly make our communities safe. These harms are not incidental to health; they fundamentally undermine our well-being.
First and foremost, CIR reiterates its call for the abolition of ICE, just as we demanded in the resolution our union passed earlier this year. Abolition alone is no longer enough; we call for more proactive measures to be taken.
To our hospital administration:
- Our hospitals must remain safe havens. We cannot allow immigration agents to invade our clinical spaces where patients are at their most vulnerable. Every employee must be adequately trained in how to respond when encountering ICE agents and have a clear policy to reference.
- We call on all NYC hospitals to adopt CIR SEIU’s Model Policy for Immigration Enforcement in the Healthcare Setting. Our hospitals must have clear protocols in place to ensure that no more patients disappear from hospitals due to ICE’s violence.
To our fellow interns, residents, physicians, nurses, and other allied health professionals:
- We must uphold the oaths we took when we entered our privileged positions. We must stand united against ICE forces to protect our patients.
- We call on our allies to continue hosting and participating in ICE preparedness trainings to better understand our patients’ rights and how to prevent future abductions.
To our legislators and policymakers:
- ICE remains a threat to our city and state so long as its actions on our streets remain unchecked. We call on you to pass legislation that establishes clear limits on immigration enforcement and holds agents accountable for their actions.
- We demand the passage of bills such as S8522A to limit ICE’s presence in hospitals in order to maintain the safety of our workplaces.
To Mayor Mamdani, Governor Hochul, and the political leaders of New York:
- We call on our executive leaders to reaffirm what it means to be a sanctuary city—a commitment earned through action, not merely by name. We are appalled by the continued cooperation of the NYPD with ICE operations. Clear policies must be established to enforce noncooperation with federal immigration enforcement.
- We demand that until these attacks end, our elected administration commit resources to fund legal defense for immigrant community members who are most vulnerable.
The over 8,000 CIR doctors in New York join our communities in calling for policies that protect the safety and civil rights of all of us. We urge our elected officials and institutions to challenge policies that place our patients and communities at risk and to advance approaches to public safety that prioritize prevention, dignity, and care over coercion.
As physicians, we have a responsibility not only to treat the consequences of harm, but also to speak out against the systems that produce it. We stand in solidarity with immigrant communities and reaffirm our commitment to a society in which everyone can live safely and be treated with dignity, regardless of immigration status.
###






